Herzog James J., the Senior EVP and CFO of Comerica (CMA), has filed 38 Form 4 transactions over the past year, all concentrated in a single company. The pattern is dominated by compensation-related events rather than discretionary trading: there are no open-market purchases (code P) or sales (code S) in the recent record. Instead, the activity breaks down into automatic and mechanical categories—option exercises (M), shares withheld for taxes (F), and equity grants or awards (A). The most recent cluster, dated February 1, 2026, consists of seven transactions coded as "D" (sale back to the issuer) with a reported value of zero, suggesting a non-cash disposition or a nominal transfer rather than a meaningful market signal.
The dollar figures that do appear are tied to option exercises and tax withholding. On November 7, 2025, Herzog exercised six tranches of options with values ranging from roughly $61,700 to $340,000, totaling about $1.12 million, while simultaneously having $1.25 million in shares withheld to cover tax obligations. A similar pattern occurred on October 28, 2025, with a $19,254 exercise offset by $29,577 in tax withholding, and on January 15, 2026, where a grant (A) was paired with $575,140 in shares withheld. The total acquired value across all filings is $420,078.60, but this reflects option exercises and awards, not cash purchases.
The absence of any open-market buying or selling is notable. Herzog has not initiated a single discretionary trade in the period covered, and the recent "D" transactions on February 1, 2026, carry no dollar value, indicating they are likely administrative in nature. The overall direction is neutral—there is no accumulation or distribution bias visible in the filings. The activity is consistent with a senior executive managing equity compensation: exercising options, receiving grants, and having shares withheld for taxes, all within the normal cadence of a CFO's compensation cycle. No recent open-market transactions suggest no conviction-based positioning in CMA shares.
AI-assisted summary